Buy or rent?

1.Input

Price €478,000 · rent €1,625 / month
Renting
Rent, charges included€1,625 / month
Rent increase1.4% / year
Renter’s home insurance€30 / month
Buying
Purchase price€478,000Loan payment€2,450 / monthRise in value2.4% / yearPlanned saleyear 25
Investing

The spending gap between buying and renting, invested each year by whoever spends less.

Net return after tax4.00% / year

2.The race between buying and renting

Buying wins by €238,368 (+40.8%) in year 25

Buying leaves you €238,368 more than renting if you sell in year 25.

Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection.

% / year
% / year
Diversified investment, 4.00% net of tax a year (default assumption). The higher this rate, the more renting is favoured.

Flat in Paris 15e — main home · ID 06

  • Buy: cash if you sell€821,581
  • Rent: the renter’s savings€583,213
€0€200,000€400,000€600,000€800,000Buying gets ahead (year 8)Y0*Y0Y5Y10Y15Y20Y25

Before purchase: €38,240 = − loan above the price €1,000 + notary €38,240 + other fees €1,000
The renter invests this same sum: we compare the same person buying or staying a renter.

What each would have if they sold or stopped that year, with the same budget every year.

For the verdict: gap at the sale (25 years): +40.8% → A

3.What the buyer and the renter pay

The buyer pays €919 / month more · heavy effort
BuyRent
Per month (average over the loan’s 25 years)€2,879€1,960
Per year (average over the loan’s 25 years)€34,550€23,516
Your household net income, after tax (per month, year 1)
€ / month
Household net income (average over the loan’s 25 years)€7,307 (for both)
Average effort over the loan term (25 years)39.4% Heavy26.8% Normal
Buy: average effort 39.4% (the verdict’s one)Rent: 26.8% (for comparison)

This effort (buying) is what puts the verdict in the Heavy column (section 4).

Buy: loan payment, loan insurance, condo fees, property tax, home insurance, upkeep, bank fees.

Rent: rent + home insurance.

Light ≤ 25 % · Normal 25 – 35 % · Heavy > 35 % (the verdict’s thresholds, applied to the average effort).

Per month, year 1 to 25: housing cost and household income

€0€2,000€4,000€6,000€8,000Y1Y5Y10Y15Y20Y25
Year 25
  • Buy€2,942
  • Rent€2,299
  • Income€8,782

Effort = the average housing cost ÷ the household’s average income, over years 1 to 25. NB: income follows inflation (+1.6% a year, property editor), the loan payment is fixed until the loan ends (25 years), rent +1.4% a year; the owner’s charges follow their own increases.

For the verdict: buying is Heavy (average effort 39.4% of income over the loan’s 25 years)

4.The verdict

Buy only if your income is secure — otherwise rent and invest

The conclusion of sections 2 and 3: the net-worth gap at the planned sale, as a % of the renter’s net worth (rows) × the average effort of buying over the loan term, at most until the sale (columns).

In year 25: buying +€238,368, i.e. +40.8% of the renter’s net worth

Buying gets ahead in year 8.

Gap +40.8% → A

Average effort over the loan term (25 years): Heavy

Gap \ effortLight≤ 25 %Normal25 – 35 %Heavy> 35 %
A · Buying wins clearly (≥ +10%)BuyBuy, if your budget stays comfortableBuy only if your income is secure — otherwise rent and invest◆ You are here
B · Buying wins a little (0 to +10%)Either — buy for stability, rent for flexibilityRather rent — buying doesn’t build enough wealth for the effortRent
C · Renting wins (< 0%)Rent — buy only for the comfort of owningRentRent

The results are estimates, not tax or financial advice.