Rental property IRR in France: why a small gap in return is a big gap in euros
Updated on
You are comparing two options for the same property and the returns look almost identical: 3.14% vs 3.81% a year. On a chart the two lines touch, and it feels like the choice doesn’t matter. In our invented example, that small gap is worth €7,995 more profit at a sale in year 16, and €24,125 in year 20, for exactly the same money out of your pocket. This guide explains why, and how to translate an IRR (in French: TRI, taux de rendement interne) into euros instead of stopping at the percentage.
The IRR in one sentence
Invented example (the site’s Example 05), computed by the simulator. Not personal advice.
The IRR measures how fast your money grows, after every tax. In the simulator it starts from this question: if every euro you put in (the cash at purchase, then each payment after the purchase) had been invested at a single yearly rate from the year it was paid in, how much would you have on the day of the sale? The IRR is the rate for which the answer is exactly your cash in hand at the end, after every tax. The simulator calls it MWRR, the money-weighted return: for a property, it is the same idea.
where:
- the yearly return on your money, after every tax[%/year]
- the year of the sale[year]
- the number of the year; year 0 is the year of the purchase
- what you put in in year t (the cash at purchase in year 0, then the payments after the purchase)[€]
- the cash in hand at the end (what is left on the account + what the sale leaves you, once the loan is repaid and the fees are paid), after every tax[€]
Example · equation (1) · SCI à l’IS (company) · sale in year 16
In the years when the rent covers everything and leaves a surplus, that money is not counted as taken out: it stays on the property’s account, earning 3% a year before tax in the example, and comes back in the cash in hand at the sale. In our example this is rare: only réel foncier leaves a surplus, and only in year 1 (€902); in every other case, you put money in. The IRR includes the loan, taxes, resale and time all at once, which a gross yield does not (see the yield calculator). It is a speed, not an amount. Full definition in the glossary; step by step in the SCI à l’IS guide.
Why a small IRR gap becomes a big euro gap
A return applies each year to what has already grown: that is compounding. A tiny gap, repeated for fifteen or twenty years, adds up.
Plain arithmetic, not property: €10,000 invested for 20 years at 3% a year becomes €18,061. At 3.7%, it becomes €20,681. The final amount is only 14.5% bigger… but the gain (€10,681 vs €8,061) is about a third bigger. And the gain is what you care about: you already had the down payment.
where:
- the amount invested at the start[€]
- the yearly rate[%/year]
- how long the money stays invested[years]
- the final amount, at the end of n years[€]
- the gain: what the investment brings on top of the starting amount[€]
Example · equation (2) · plain arithmetic, not property
Another habit: read an IRR gap in points, not in percent. Going from 3.14% to 3.81% is 0.7 points more, i.e. a return about 21% higher.
The example: the same flat, in an SCI à l’IS or as LMNP
The property: a 62 m² three-room flat in Melun, near Paris (invented example), bought for €152,000 with €24,000 of works, financed with a €160,000 loan over 25 years at 3.35% and let for €950 a month including charges. We simulated it under two French tax regimes, with exactly the same figures and a 30% marginal income-tax rate: an SCI à l’IS (a property company that pays corporate tax) and LMNP réel (furnished letting in your own name: actual expenses and depreciation deducted). LMNP assumes a furnished let: the simulator keeps the same rent and counts no furniture, to isolate the effect of the tax regime.
| SCI à l’IS (company) | LMNP (régime réel) | |
|---|---|---|
| Return per year (MWRR, after all taxes) | 3.14% | 3.81% |
| Total cash put in | €57,898 | €57,898 |
| Tax paid during ownership | €0 | €0 |
| Tax paid at sale | €22,218 | €14,222 |
| Cash in hand at the end, after all taxes | €87,448 | €95,443 |
| Total profit | €29,550 | €37,545 |
| SCI à l’IS (company) | LMNP (régime réel) | |
|---|---|---|
| Return per year (MWRR, after all taxes) | 3.54% | 4.74% |
| Total cash put in | €59,556 | €59,556 |
| Tax paid during ownership | €0 | €0 |
| Tax paid at sale | €39,705 | €15,580 |
| Cash in hand at the end, after all taxes | €107,638 | €131,763 |
| Total profit | €48,082 | €72,207 |
Total cash put in = cash at purchase + payments after the purchase. Total cash put in + Total profit = Cash in hand at the end.
In both cases the same money leaves your pocket (€57,898 if you sell in year 16). In this example, neither regime charges any tax on the rent during the holding period: the gap comes from the tax at the sale (€22,218 vs €14,222 in year 16).
In an SCI à l’IS, the company pays corporate tax on its gain, measured against net book value (the price minus depreciation): €8,692 here. Then you pay the 31.4% flat tax (prélèvement forfaitaire unique, PFU) on what it distributes to you beyond the repayment of your shareholder loan (compte courant d’associé): €13,526. The simulator applies the PFU, not the option for the progressive income-tax scale. As LMNP, you pay the private-individual capital-gains tax (€14,222 here): the depreciation you deducted is added back (Article 84 of the 2025 Finance Act, for sales made since 15 February 2025, except for property located in a student or senior residence, an EHPAD care home or another establishment for elderly or disabled people, or a long-term care establishment), but holding-period allowances apply from the 6th year and increase every year, up to a full exemption: from income tax after 22 years of ownership, from social levies after 30 years. That is why the gap widens over time: 0.7 points in year 16, 1.2 points in year 20.
Result: LMNP réel leaves €37,545 of profit against €29,550 for SCI à l’IS in year 16 (+27%), and €72,207 against €48,082 in year 20 (+50%).
Why the IRR chart flattens the gap
On the “Return (MWRR) over time” chart of the “Compare my simulations” page, each point answers “what if I sold that year?” Selling in year 1 means paying the purchase and sale costs for next to nothing: you lose most of what you put in, sometimes more, and the return shown drops to -100%. So the axis runs from -100% up to a few percent, and two lines about one point apart look glued together. The gap is real; the scale hides it.
Return (MWRR) over time — if you sell that year, after all taxes
- SCI à l’IS (company)3.54%
- LMNP (régime réel)4.74%
That is why the page has a second chart in euros, “Your wealth over time”: the cash in hand if you sell that year, after every tax. There, the gap shows: €95,443 vs €87,448 in year 16.
Your wealth over time — if you sell that year, after all taxes
- SCI à l’IS (company)€107,638
- LMNP (régime réel)€131,763
The opposite trap: the cash in hand doesn’t say how much you put in
The cash in hand at the end is only an amount. It doesn’t tell you how much money you had to put in to get it. Same example, let unfurnished this time, sold in year 20, under micro-foncier or under réel foncier:
| Micro-foncier | Réel foncier | |
|---|---|---|
| Return per year (MWRR, after all taxes) | 0.97% | 3.69% |
| Total cash put in | €130,499 | €91,318 |
| Tax paid during ownership | €70,759 | €31,634 |
| Tax paid at sale | €0 | €0 |
| Cash in hand at the end, after all taxes | €147,526 | €147,499 |
| Total profit | €17,027 | €56,181 |
Total cash put in = cash at purchase + payments after the purchase. Total cash put in + Total profit = Cash in hand at the end.
Your wealth over time — if you sell that year, after all taxes
- Micro-foncier€147,526
- Réel foncier€147,499
Both end with almost the same cash in hand (€147,526 and €147,499): on the wealth chart the two lines sit on top of each other. Yet the profit ranges from €17,027 to €56,181 depending on the regime. Under micro-foncier, a flat 30% allowance replaces every expense (available, with exceptions set by Article 32 of the CGI, if the household’s gross property income, rent excluding charges and SCPI shares included, stays at or below €15,000 a year); under réel foncier, the actual expenses are deducted: loan interest, works, co-ownership charges, property tax. Here the allowance is smaller than the actual expenses: the tax on the rent is heavier under micro-foncier (€70,759 vs €31,634 over the period), and it is paid every year from your pocket. Almost the same cash at the end, but you put much more in to get it (€130,499 vs €91,318). The IRR, for its part, is not fooled: 0.97% under micro-foncier against 3.69% under réel foncier. It is the cash in hand that misleads.
Hence the line the comparison page shows for every simulation: Total cash put in + Total profit = Cash in hand at the end. Comparing the cash in hand without the cash put in is like comparing two piggy banks without knowing how much went into each.
where:
- the cash in hand at the end, after every tax[€]
- the total cash put in: the cash at purchase + the payments after the purchase, simply added up (without growing them)[€]
- the total profit[€]
Example · equation (3) · sale in year 20, unfurnished
Reading a regime comparison in three questions
- Is the total cash put in the same? If so, the gap in cash in hand equals the gap in profit. If not, look at the total profit, not the cash in hand.
- How many euros of profit in the year you plan to sell? That is the number that matters. The gap changes with the horizon: compare the regimes in the year you plan to sell, and a few years before and after.
- Then the IRR, for the speed: useful to compare with an investment (a euro fund, an ETF), another property or another holding period. A few tenths of a point over fifteen years or more is rarely negligible.
The limits of this example
Same rent under every regime (furnished flats often rent for more), no furniture counted, a 30% tax bracket, the property’s value up 1% a year and the rent up 1.5% a year, as set in the example. The same running costs under every regime: a company’s own costs (an accountant, for example) are not added to the SCI. Some calculation choices still need an accountant’s confirmation, and the simulator does not model everything: see the methodology. This guide is not personal advice.
Re-run the calculation
- Try Example 05 in the simulator: switch the tax regime, then look at the results in year 16 and in year 20.
- Example 05’s report (saved under réel foncier).
- Compare my simulations (free account): save your property, duplicate it, switch the copy’s tax regime, then compare up to 4 simulations on one page.
- LMNP or SCI à l’IS: which regime leaves you more at resale?
- SCI à l’IS: the real return
Frequently asked questions
What is a good IRR for a rental property?
There is no universal threshold. Compare it with what the same money would have earned elsewhere over the same period, and always look at the profit in euros next to it: an IRR alone doesn’t say how much you put in.
What is the difference between the IRR and the gross or net yield?
A yield is a snapshot taken over a single year (the rent against the price; for the net yield, the rent minus expenses). The IRR follows all the money over time, from the first euro put in to the sale, after the loan and every tax.
Why is my IRR negative in the first years?
Selling early means paying the purchase and sale costs before they have been earned back. In our example, the return shown for year 1 is -100%. It is not a real loss as long as you keep the property.
Does a higher IRR always mean more money?
No. If one regime makes you put in more money, it can earn more in euros at a lower IRR, or the reverse. Look at the total profit, against the total cash put in.
Do a few tenths of a point of IRR matter?
Over fifteen or twenty years, yes. In this guide’s illustration (plain arithmetic, not property), 0.7 points more return gives a gain about a third bigger. For the exact amount, run your own property.
Is the simulator’s IRR the same as Excel’s IRR function?
Yes, for identical flows. It is the same equation as Excel’s IRR() function, applied to your own flows only: the cash at purchase as a negative in year 0, each payment as a negative in the year it is made, and the final cash as a positive in the sale year. If you enter the property’s yearly surpluses in Excel as money received, you are computing a different IRR: the simulator leaves them on the property’s account, and they come back in the final cash. One display difference: when all the money put in is lost, Excel returns an error (#NUM!) where the simulator shows -100%.
How do I compare French tax regimes for my property?
With a free account, on the “Compare my simulations” page: save your property, duplicate it, switch the copy’s tax regime (SCI à l’IS, LMNP, micro-foncier, réel foncier…), then pick up to 4 simulations. Each shows exactly the figures of its report.