How it is calculated, and the risks
The figures on this page are the property’s as saved (saved rent, income and sliders): an unsaved trial on the « Buy or rent? » page does not show here.
Year by year
| Year | Budget | Buy: cost | Rent: rent and insurance | Buy: cash if sold + investments | Rent: savings | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | €23,806 | €23,806 | €16,968 | €776 | €43,238 | −€42,462 |
| 2 | €23,864 | €23,864 | €17,204 | €13,887 | €51,627 | −€37,741 |
| 3 | €23,922 | €23,922 | €17,443 | €27,358 | €60,171 | −€32,813 |
| 4 | €23,981 | €23,981 | €17,686 | €41,203 | €68,873 | −€27,670 |
| 5 | €24,041 | €24,041 | €17,931 | €55,432 | €77,738 | −€22,305 |
| 6 | €24,102 | €24,102 | €18,181 | €70,058 | €86,768 | −€16,710 |
| 7 | €24,163 | €24,163 | €18,434 | €85,092 | €95,968 | −€10,876 |
| 8 | €24,226 | €24,226 | €18,690 | €100,548 | €105,343 | −€4,795 |
| 9 | €24,289 | €24,289 | €18,950 | €116,439 | €114,896 | €1,543 |
| 10 | €24,353 | €24,353 | €19,214 | €132,778 | €124,631 | €8,147 |
| 11 | €24,419 | €24,419 | €19,481 | €149,579 | €134,554 | €15,025 |
| 12 | €24,485 | €24,485 | €19,752 | €166,858 | €144,669 | €22,189 |
| 13 | €24,552 | €24,552 | €20,027 | €184,628 | €154,981 | €29,648 |
| 14 | €24,620 | €24,620 | €20,306 | €202,906 | €165,494 | €37,412 |
| 15 | €24,689 | €24,689 | €20,588 | €221,708 | €176,214 | €45,494 |
| 16 | €24,758 | €24,758 | €20,875 | €241,049 | €187,146 | €53,903 |
| 17 | €24,829 | €24,829 | €21,165 | €260,948 | €198,296 | €62,652 |
| 18 | €24,901 | €24,901 | €21,460 | €281,422 | €209,669 | €71,753 |
| 19 | €24,974 | €24,974 | €21,759 | €302,489 | €221,271 | €81,219 |
| 20 | €25,048 | €25,048 | €22,062 | €324,169 | €233,108 | €91,061 |
| 21 | €25,123 | €25,123 | €22,369 | €346,480 | €245,186 | €101,294 |
| 22 | €25,199 | €25,199 | €22,680 | €369,443 | €257,511 | €111,931 |
| 23 | €25,276 | €25,276 | €22,996 | €393,078 | €270,091 | €122,987 |
| 24 | €25,354 | €25,354 | €23,316 | €417,408 | €282,932 | €134,476 |
| 25 | €25,433 | €25,433 | €23,641 | €442,454 | €296,041 | €146,413 |
How it is calculated
- Buy: exactly the figures of the main-home report (loan payments, costs, sale), plus what the owner invests.
- At the start, the renter invests all the money the buyer puts in at the purchase (down payment, fees, works).
- Then, every year, both take the same budget out of their pocket: the higher of what the buyer pays (counting the loan payments to the end, even once the loan is repaid) and the rent + insurance. Whoever pays less invests the difference: the renter while renting is cheaper, the owner once the loan is repaid (the payments no longer made) or when the rent is above the owner’s costs.
- The investments earn d, what your money earns elsewhere, already after tax (the rate you choose; by default, a diversified investment at 4% a year net of tax): no tax is added on top.
Renting means investing with discipline. This comparison assumes each really invests, every year, everything not spent on housing, and leaves it alone: the renter, and the owner once the loan is repaid. Without that discipline the advantage of renting disappears: during the loan the buyer, on the other hand, is forced to “save” by repaying it.
The risks, in plain words
- The home’s price can fall: at the sale the buyer gets back less, and the buying and selling costs are lost. The sooner the sale, the bigger the risk.
- Interest rates: with a fixed rate your payment does not move; but a dearer loan at the time you buy changes the whole calculation.
- Selling early is costly: notary fees, the agency fee at the sale and the first years’ interest weigh heavily over few years.
- The investment goes up and down: an average return of a few % a year hides years of falls. If you must sell during a fall, you sell at a loss.
- Tax: the gain on a main home is exempt; the renter’s rate d is a securities-account return after tax. Another account (PEA, assurance-vie) would change that rate.
Precautionary savings: it is generally advised to keep about 6 months of housing costs aside, i.e. ~€12,300 for buying (€10,100 for renting), based on the average monthly cost over the loan’s 25 years.
The price of peace of mind: in money going out each month (resale excluded), buying takes on average €371 more than renting over the loan’s 25 years; in return you end up with ~€146,000 more at the sale.
To lighten the effort
- Borrow less: a bigger down payment or a cheaper home.
- Check the job-loss cover of the loan insurance.
Keep in mind
- In a crisis, jobs and prices often fall together.
- The home’s value is not money you can spend: you have to sell to get it.
- The renter’s cushion exists only if they really invest the difference.
- A couple losing one income of two is less exposed than a single person.
An estimate, not financial advice.