Buy or rent: from when buying is ahead — Flat in Paris 15e — main home · ID 06Main homeFirst year from which buying stays ahead, and the first year ahead
Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection.
Where each number comes from
Each link opens the page that calculates that figure.
- Buy or rent: what each would have Buyer: cash if sold + investments; renter: savings
- Cash at the end if you sell Sale price − selling costs − loans still owed + unspent down payment
- What the sale leaves after the loan and fees Net Sale Proceeds Ledger
- Tax: none while you own it, none at the sale No rent → no income tax; gain exempt (CGI art. 150 U, II-1°)
- Payments after the purchase Unspent down payment used first, then what you pay after the purchase
- What each invests, year by year The same budget on both sides; the renter’s savings and the owner’s investments at the rate d
- Cash at purchase Down payment + works + furniture (+ the shortfall you cover when the loan is not enough)
- Payments after the purchase Unspent down payment used first, then what you pay after the purchase
- Cash at purchase Down payment + works + furniture (+ the shortfall you cover when the loan is not enough)
- Money lost and principal repaid, year by year Yearly outflow = money lost + principal repaid
- Loan paid off (equity built) Equity from Loan
- Cash at the end if you sell Sale price − selling costs − loans still owed + unspent down payment
- What you pay each month One year’s outflow ÷ 12, line by line
- Money lost and principal repaid, year by year Yearly outflow = money lost + principal repaid
- Loan paid off (equity built) Equity from Loan
- Money lost and principal repaid, year by year Yearly outflow = money lost + principal repaid
- Cash at the end if you sell Sale price − selling costs − loans still owed + unspent down payment
Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection.
Part 1. The gap, year by year
| Year | Buy: cash if you sell + investments | Rent: savings | Gap (buy − rent) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | €0 | €60,584 | -€60,584 |
| 2 | €16,803 | €69,728 | -€52,924 |
| 3 | €41,142 | €86,083 | -€44,941 |
| 4 | €66,242 | €102,864 | -€36,622 |
| 5 | €92,126 | €120,084 | -€27,958 |
| 6 | €118,821 | €137,757 | -€18,936 |
| 7 | €146,354 | €155,899 | -€9,545 |
| 8 | €174,751 | €174,524 | €227 |
| 9 | €204,042 | €193,649 | €10,392 |
| 10 | €234,255 | €213,291 | €20,965 |
| 11 | €265,422 | €233,465 | €31,956 |
| 12 | €297,573 | €254,191 | €43,381 |
| 13 | €330,741 | €275,487 | €55,254 |
| 14 | €364,959 | €297,371 | €67,588 |
| 15 | €400,264 | €319,864 | €80,400 |
| 16 | €436,690 | €342,986 | €93,703 |
| 17 | €474,274 | €366,759 | €107,515 |
| 18 | €513,056 | €391,205 | €121,851 |
| 19 | €553,075 | €416,347 | €136,729 |
| 20 | €594,373 | €442,208 | €152,165 |
| 21 | €636,991 | €468,814 | €168,177 |
| 22 | €680,975 | €496,190 | €184,785 |
| 23 | €726,369 | €524,364 | €202,006 |
| 24 | €773,222 | €553,362 | €219,860 |
| 25 | €821,581 | €583,213 | €238,368 |