Buy or rent: from when buying is ahead — Flat in Paris 15e — main home · ID 06Main homeFirst year from which buying stays ahead, and the first year ahead

Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection.

Where each number comes from

Each link opens the page that calculates that figure.

  1. Buy or rent: what each would have Buyer: cash if sold + investments; renter: savings
    1. Cash at the end if you sell Sale price − selling costs − loans still owed + unspent down payment
      1. What the sale leaves after the loan and fees Net Sale Proceeds Ledger
      2. Tax: none while you own it, none at the sale No rent → no income tax; gain exempt (CGI art. 150 U, II-1°)
      3. Payments after the purchase Unspent down payment used first, then what you pay after the purchase
    2. What each invests, year by year The same budget on both sides; the renter’s savings and the owner’s investments at the rate d
      1. Cash at purchase Down payment + works + furniture (+ the shortfall you cover when the loan is not enough)
      2. Payments after the purchase Unspent down payment used first, then what you pay after the purchase
        1. Cash at purchase Down payment + works + furniture (+ the shortfall you cover when the loan is not enough)
        2. Money lost and principal repaid, year by year Yearly outflow = money lost + principal repaid
          1. Loan paid off (equity built) Equity from Loan
        3. Cash at the end if you sell Sale price − selling costs − loans still owed + unspent down payment
      3. What you pay each month One year’s outflow ÷ 12, line by line
        1. Money lost and principal repaid, year by year Yearly outflow = money lost + principal repaid
          1. Loan paid off (equity built) Equity from Loan

Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection.

Part 1. The gap, year by year
YearBuy: cash if you sell + investmentsRent: savingsGap (buy − rent)
1€0€60,584-€60,584
2€16,803€69,728-€52,924
3€41,142€86,083-€44,941
4€66,242€102,864-€36,622
5€92,126€120,084-€27,958
6€118,821€137,757-€18,936
7€146,354€155,899-€9,545
8€174,751€174,524€227
9€204,042€193,649€10,392
10€234,255€213,291€20,965
11€265,422€233,465€31,956
12€297,573€254,191€43,381
13€330,741€275,487€55,254
14€364,959€297,371€67,588
15€400,264€319,864€80,400
16€436,690€342,986€93,703
17€474,274€366,759€107,515
18€513,056€391,205€121,851
19€553,075€416,347€136,729
20€594,373€442,208€152,165
21€636,991€468,814€168,177
22€680,975€496,190€184,785
23€726,369€524,364€202,006
24€773,222€553,362€219,860
25€821,581€583,213€238,368