Buy or rent your home in France: when does buying come out ahead?

Updated on

"Renting is throwing money away." Half true. Rent never comes back, that’s right. But an owner also pays money every month that never comes back: loan interest, borrower insurance, taxe foncière (property tax), building charges, upkeep. On top of that come the notary fees when you buy and the selling costs when you sell. So the real question isn’t "rent or loan payment". It is this: with the same budget every month, who ends up wealthier: the person who buys, or the one who keeps renting and invests the difference? And does the purchase fit your income? This guide runs the full calculation, from purchase to sale, on an invented example computed by the simulator.

The example at a glance

An invented example (the site’s Example 06: a 58 m² flat in Paris 15e), computed by the simulator. Not personal advice: your city, price, income and holding period change the answer.

Example 06: the assumptions
Example 06
Purchase price
Purchase price€478,000
Notary fees · other purchase fees
Notary fees · other purchase fees€38,240 (estimated at 8% of the price) · €1,000
Cash at purchase
Cash at purchase€38,240 (the notary fees)
Loan
Loan€479,000 (the price and the other purchase fees) over 25 years at 3.70% (loan payment €2,450 a month, borrower insurance on top)
Property tax · building charges
Property tax · building charges€100 a month · €200 a month
Assumed rise in value
Assumed rise in value2.4% a year
Planned sale
Planned saleyear 25
Rent of an equivalent home (charges included)
Rent of an equivalent home (charges included)€1,625 a month, rising 1.4% a year, plus €30 of home insurance
Return on invested money, net of tax
Return on invested money, net of tax4% a year
Household net income (example)
Household net income (example)€6,000 a month

1. Comparing the loan payment with the rent is not enough

In the first year the example’s owner pays €2,823 a month on average, all costs included. Over the year, that €33,875 splits in two:

Year 1: money lost and principal repaid
Year 1Amount
Loan interest€17,523
Borrower insurance€719
Property tax (taxe foncière)€1,200
Building charges (copropriété)€2,400
Home insurance€160
Money lost, year 1€22,002
Principal repaid (wealth built), year 1€11,873
Total paid, year 1€33,875

Principal repaid is not an expense: it lowers what you owe the bank, so it comes back when you sell (less debt to clear). Only the money lost never comes back. A renter loses the whole rent.

The principal share grows over time, because interest falls as the loan is repaid. In year 25, 81.6% of what the owner pays becomes principal (€28,815 out of €35,301).

Where your money goes, year by year (Example 06)

Example 06: where your money goes each year

€0€10,000€20,000€30,000€34,354€34,648€34,963€35,301Avg capital built: €19,160/yryears 1–25, i.e. 55.5% of what you payY1Y5Y10Y15Y20Y25
Year 25 — 81.6% of what you pay becomes capital
  • Principal repaid€28,815
  • =Capital built per year€28,815
  • Home insurance, bank fees€160
  • Co-ownership charges€3,351
  • Taxe foncière (property tax)€1,675
  • Loan insurance€719
  • Loan interest€581
  • Total paid in the year€35,301
  • 25-year average capital built€19,160/yr

In the simulator’s summary, the "Total monthly payment" (€2,879 a month) is the average of everything you pay each month (loan, borrower insurance, property tax, building charges, home insurance), averaged from year 1 to the sale. That figure, not the bare loan payment (€2,450), is the one to keep in mind before buying.

2. What buying costs, from signing to selling

Over the example’s 25 years:

  • money lost while you own it: €384,742;
  • principal repaid: €479,000, which comes back at the sale;
  • at purchase, €38,240 of notary fees and €1,000 of other purchase costs (inside the loan); at the sale, €43,241 of selling costs (agency fee; the loan is over, no early repayment).

Sold in year 25, the home fetches €864,822 (with 2.4% a year of growth). The loan is then fully repaid: only €43,241 of selling costs come off. No capital gains tax: it’s a main home (section 9). What’s left is €821,581 of "Cash in hand at the end".

Against that, the owner put in €38,240 at purchase and then €863,742 of "Payments after the purchase": a "Total cash put in" of €901,982. So they get back less than they put in. That isn’t bad news in itself: for those 25 years they had a home. To know whether buying was worth it, you have to compare it with what housing yourself as a renter would have cost. That’s what comes next.

3. The buy-vs-rent race, with the same budget

The simulator compares the same person in two lives.

  • They buy this home.
  • They keep renting an equivalent home. The cash at purchase (€38,240) isn’t spent: it’s invested at 4% a year net of tax.
  • Every year both have the same budget. Whoever spends less that year invests the difference at the same rate. Early on that’s usually the renter. Later, once the rent has risen and the loan weighs less, it can be the buyer.

Each year we look at what each would have if they stopped there: the buyer if they sold (investments included), the renter with their savings.

The buy-vs-rent race (Example 06)
Stop in yearBuy: cash if you sellRent: the renter’s savingsWho is ahead?
Year 5
Year 5€92,126€120,084renting ahead by €27,958
Year 8
Year 8€174,751€174,524buying ahead by €227
Year 10
Year 10€234,255€213,291buying ahead by €20,965
Year 15
Year 15€400,264€319,864buying ahead by €80,400
Year 25
Year 25€821,581€583,213buying ahead by €238,368

Buying gets ahead in year 8 and stays ahead to the end of the projection. At the planned sale, in year 25, buying leaves you €238,368 more than renting, i.e. +40.8% of the renter’s net worth.

The race’s "cash if you sell" in year 25 (€821,581) is the summary’s "Cash in hand at the end": here the buyer spends more than the renter every year, so there is nothing to invest. See the example’s race in the simulator.

Example 06’s buy-vs-rent race

Example 06: the race between buying and renting

  • Buy: cash if you sell€821,581
  • Rent: the renter’s savings€583,213
€0€200,000€400,000€600,000€800,000Buying gets ahead (year 8)Y0*Y0Y5Y10Y15Y20Y25

Before purchase: €38,240 = − loan above the price €1,000 + notary €38,240 + other fees €1,000
The renter invests this same sum: we compare the same person buying or staying a renter.

What each would have if they stopped that year. The same budget every year; whoever pays less invests the difference (the owner, for example, once the loan is repaid). The legend shows the sale-year values.

4. Time decides: what if you sell earlier?

This is what most comparisons leave out. Notary fees are paid on day one, selling costs on the last day, and in the first years the loan payment is mostly interest. The longer you stay, the more those costs are spread out.

In the example, if you sell in year 5, renting is ahead by €27,958. That’s an honest answer, and it holds for many first purchases: a job move, a baby or a separation can come before buying has caught up with renting. So before buying, the right question is also: how long will I really stay?

5. The effort on your income

Winning the race isn’t enough: you also have to hold the budget. The "Buy or rent?" page compares what the buyer and the renter pay, on average per month while you repay the loan, or up to the sale if it comes first:

  • buy: €2,879 a month (loan payment, loan insurance, building charges, property tax, home insurance);
  • rent: €1,960 a month (rent and home insurance).

Here the buyer pays €919 a month more.

You then enter your household’s net monthly income, after tax (right in that section). The simulator works out the effort: the share of your income the purchase takes, on average over the loan term, up to the sale at most. The verdict’s thresholds:

  • Light: up to 25% of your income;
  • Normal: 25% to 35%;
  • Heavy: above 35%.

These are the simulator’s reference points, not a bank rule.

With the example’s €6,000 of net income a month, the renter spends 26.8% of their income on housing ("Normal"), the buyer 39.4% ("Heavy"). The buyer’s effort is what puts the verdict in its column; the renter’s is there to compare.

Example 06’s effort: renting and buying

Average housing cost ÷ average net household income, over the 25 years of the loan. Same scale for both bars; the verdict’s thresholds at 25% and 35%.

6. The verdict: gap at the sale × effort

The verdict crosses the two answers. Rows: the net-worth gap at the planned sale, as a percentage of the renter’s net worth. Columns: the effort.

The verdict grid (the app’s texts)
Gap \ effortLightNormalHeavy
A · Buying wins clearly (at least +10%)
A · Buying wins clearly (at least +10%)BuyBuy, if your budget stays comfortableBuy only if your income is secure — otherwise rent and invest
B · Buying wins a little (zero to +10%)
B · Buying wins a little (zero to +10%)Either — buy for stability, rent for flexibilityRather rent — buying doesn’t build enough wealth for the effortRent
C · Renting wins (negative gap)
C · Renting wins (negative gap)Rent — buy only for the comfort of owningRentRent

The example is in row A: in year 25, buying wins by +40.8%. With €6,000 of net income a month (an example income), the average effort is 39.4%, "Heavy": verdict "Buy only if your income is secure — otherwise rent and invest". That income is assumed to follow inflation (1.6% a year) over the loan term, so the 39.4% is not the total monthly payment divided by that starting income. For you, the column depends on your own income.

The same home sold in year 5 would fall in row C: time changes the verdict as much as price does.

7. The assumptions that tip the result

Three settings weigh more than the others. The "Buy or rent?" page lets you change two of them in one move.

  • The rise in the home’s value. The example assumes 2.4% a year; the simulator’s default is 1.4%. It’s the only line that clearly favours the buyer, and it’s an assumption, not a certainty. With no rise at all, the gap at the sale would be -€129,113: renting would be ahead.
  • The return on invested money. Default 4% a year net of tax, the assumption of a diversified investment. The higher this rate, the more renting is favoured.
  • The loan rate. The example is entered at 3.70%. The simulator’s "Estimate" button suggests the current average rate for your term (3.85% over 25 years, source Pretto, November 2026).

The next section turns these settings one at a time, together with holding period and income, on another home.

8. The five settings that change everything

Example 06 gives one answer for one set of assumptions. To see what moves it, we take another, smaller Paris home: a two-room flat (2 pièces) of 43 m² in Paris’s 18th arrondissement, on sale for €329,000 (a real listing, only the facts are reused), against renting the same flat for €1,404 a month, charges included. Cash at purchase €35,000 (of which €26,320 notary fees, estimated at 8%), loan over 25 years at 3.40%, household net income €6,000 a month, value rising 1.4% a year and rent 1.4% a year, planned sale in year 25. As everywhere in the simulator, the renter invests the cash at purchase, then each year whoever spends less invests the difference, at 4% a year net of tax. See this home’s race in the simulator.

The base case. Buying gets ahead in year 9. In year 25, buying leaves €146,413 more than renting (+49.4% of the renter’s net worth). The average effort is 28.0% of income, "Normal". The simulator’s verdict: "Buy, if your budget stays comfortable".

Then we turn one setting at a time, everything else unchanged.

Setting 1: how long you stay

In the first year, the buyer is €42,462 behind the renter: the notary fees (€26,320) are paid on day one. The gap closes slowly: still €4,795 behind in year 8, then buying gets ahead in year 9.

Setting 1: the sale year
Sale in yearGap at the sale (buy − rent)Simulator’s verdict
Year 5
Year 5-€22,305Rent
Year 10
Year 10+€8,147Rather rent — buying doesn’t build enough wealth for the effort
Year 15
Year 15+€45,494Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
Year 25
Year 25+€146,413Buy, if your budget stays comfortable

Sold in year 5, renting wins. Even in year 10, buying is ahead but not by enough for the effort: the simulator doesn’t yet recommend buying. In year 15: "Buy, if your budget stays comfortable".

Setting 2: the share of your income

The gap at the sale doesn’t depend on your income: +€146,413 in all three cases. What changes is the effort, i.e. what the home costs each month as a share of household income, averaged while you repay the loan (or up to the sale if it comes first).

Setting 2: household income
Household net incomeEffortSimulator’s verdict
€4,500 a month
€4,500 a monthHeavyBuy only if your income is secure — otherwise rent and invest
€6,000 a month
€6,000 a monthNormalBuy, if your budget stays comfortable
€8,000 a month
€8,000 a monthLightBuy

A payment that is too heavy means the risk of having to sell at the wrong moment after a setback, and setting 1 shows what selling too early costs.

Setting 3: what invested money earns

This is the most debatable assumption in the calculation: the return, net of tax, on the money the renter invests (the cash at purchase, then the difference each year). No specific investment is meant, and no return is guaranteed.

Setting 3: the net return on invested money
Net return a yearBuying gets aheadGap in year 25Simulator’s verdict
2%
2%year 8+€235,653Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
4%
4%year 9+€146,413Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
6%
6%year 14+€14,701Rather rent — buying doesn’t build enough wealth for the effort
8%
8%never-€179,800Rent

Same flat, same rent: only the return changes, and at 8% the verdict flips.

Setting 4: the price at the sale

The base case uses the simulator’s default rise, 1.4% a year. It’s an assumption, not a certainty.

Setting 4: the rise in the home’s value
Value rise a yearBuying gets aheadGap in year 25Simulator’s verdict
-1%
-1%never-€52,933Rent
0%
0%year 22+€16,509Rather rent — buying doesn’t build enough wealth for the effort
1.4%
1.4%year 9+€146,413Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
3%
3%year 5+€358,369Buy, if your budget stays comfortable

Only the home’s value changes here: rent, property tax and building charges keep their base rise. Buying is also a bet on the resale price.

Setting 5: the loan rate

Setting 5: the loan rate over 25 years
Rate over 25 yearsTotal monthly payment (average)Buying gets aheadGap in year 25Simulator’s verdict
2.50%
2.50%€1,898year 6+€221,340Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
3.40%
3.40%€2,048year 9+€146,413Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
3.85% (the simulator’s "Estimate" rate in November 2026)
3.85% (the simulator’s "Estimate" rate in November 2026)€2,126year 12+€107,371Buy, if your budget stays comfortable
4.50%
4.50%€2,243year 18+€49,173Buy, if your budget stays comfortable

Here buying still wins at the sale in every case, but between 2.50% and 4.50% it takes 12 more years to get ahead.

9. The tax rules that matter for a main home

  • No capital gains tax when you sell. Selling your main home (résidence principale) is exempt from income tax and social charges (prélèvements sociaux), whatever the gain, provided it is still your main home on the day of the sale (CGI art. 150 U, II-1°, the French General Tax Code; service-public.gouv.fr, page F10864). If you move out before selling, the exemption still applies if the sale happens within a "normal period" (délai normal), in principle one year at most, and the home was neither let nor lent in the meantime (BOFiP BOI-RFPI-PVI-10-40-10 § 190). The simulator doesn’t compute that case.
  • Housing tax (taxe d’habitation): no difference any more. It has been abolished on main homes since 1 January 2023, for owners and tenants alike (service-public.gouv.fr, page F42).
  • Property tax (taxe foncière) is the owner’s. It is owed by whoever owns the home on 1 January, even if it is let (service-public.gouv.fr, page F59). A tenant doesn’t pay it (only the household-waste charge, TEOM, can be passed on). It is part of the example’s money lost.
  • Notary fees: mostly transfer duties (droits de mutation, DMTO). For sales from 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2028, départements may raise their rate above 4.50%, up to 5%. That increase does not apply to first-time buyers (primo-accédants) buying their main home: people who haven’t owned their main home in the 2 years before the purchase. They pay the usual rate, not zero (BOFiP BOI-ENR-DMTOI-10-20 § 105 to 107; 2025 Finance Act, art. 116). Ask your notary for your département’s rate (the official list, updated monthly: impots.gouv.fr, registration duties (in French)). In the example, the notary fees (€38,240) are the simulator’s automatic estimate (8% of the price), not a duty calculation.

10. What this calculation leaves out

  • The renter’s entry costs (agency fees, deposit): renting counts only rent and home insurance.
  • Aid: the example has no zero-rate loan (PTZ) or employer loan, and the property editor can’t take one yet.
  • Upkeep and large works (façade, roof): the example counts none (upkeep entered at €0), which favours buying. Enter yours in the property sheet.
  • What can’t be priced: stability, freedom to move, the right to fit the place out as you like, the risk of having to sell at a bad moment.
  • Money left over after the purchase earns nothing on the buyer’s side, in the summary, not in the race: it pays the home’s costs first.

Every assumption and its limits are in the methodology.

11. What if you bought to let?

Many first-time buyers hesitate between buying their own home and first investing in a flat they let out. The calculation then changes completely: there’s rent, so tax, and the choice of tax regime matters a lot. With an account, a main home’s "Check if it’s a good deal" button recreates the same home as a rental (LMNP, furnished letting), same price, same loan, same address, to judge it as an investment. Example 06’s flat, for instance, would then be let furnished at the race’s rent (€1,625 a month): the rent becomes taxable, and the capital gain at the sale is no longer exempt as it is for a main home. To go further:

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to buy or rent your main home in France?

It depends on four things: the price compared with local rents, how long you’ll stay, what your money would earn elsewhere, and how much of your income the purchase takes. The simulator compares the same person buying or renting with the same budget, then crosses the net-worth gap at the sale with your effort. In our example, sold in year 25, buying leaves €238,368 more than renting.

After how many years does buying beat renting?

There’s no universal answer: it depends on the city, the price, the rate and your investments. In our example, buying gets ahead in year 8. Sold in year 5, renting is still ahead by €27,958.

Is renting throwing money away?

No more than buying. Rent is lost, but an owner loses money every year too: interest, borrower insurance, property tax, charges, upkeep, plus notary fees, other purchase costs and selling costs. In our example, the money lost while owning reaches €384,742 over 25 years. Only the principal repaid (€479,000) comes back at the sale.

Should you compare the loan payment with the rent?

No. The loan payment mixes money lost (interest, insurance) with principal repaid, which comes back to you. And it leaves out property tax, building charges and upkeep. In our example, in the first year, €33,875 is paid, of which €22,002 is money lost and €11,873 principal.

What happens if I sell my main home after a few years?

Notary and selling costs haven’t had time to be spread out, and the first payments were mostly interest. In our example, sold in year 5, renting would have left €27,958 more.

What if property prices stagnate or fall?

The rise in value is the only line that clearly favours the buyer. On the "Buy or rent?" page you can change it in one move and watch the race recompute. Our example assumes 2.4% a year. With no rise at all, the gap at the sale would be -€129,113.

Do you pay capital gains tax when selling your main home in France?

No, neither income tax nor social charges, if it is still your main home on the day of the sale (CGI art. 150 U, II-1°). After moving out, the sale must happen within a "normal period", in principle one year at most, with the home neither let nor lent in the meantime.

Should I invest my down payment instead of buying?

That’s exactly what the buy-vs-rent race measures: the renter invests the cash at purchase and, each year they spend less, the difference, at 4% a year net of tax. If your money can earn clearly more without more risk, renting becomes more attractive. The simulator lets you choose that rate.

Which settings tip the decision to buy or rent?

Five weigh heavily: how long you stay before selling, the share of your income the purchase takes, the return on invested money, how the home’s price moves, and the loan rate. On the two-room flat (2 pièces) of section 8, a sale in year 5 hands the advantage to renting, as do a net return of 8% or a value changing by -1% a year; between a 2.50% and a 4.50% rate, buying takes 12 more years to get ahead. No single setting decides.

Learn more

Informational content based on an invented example and on the tax rules in force on 4 October 2026. It does not constitute legal, tax or investment advice; rates and rules may change. Have your situation checked by a chartered accountant (expert-comptable) or a tax lawyer (avocat fiscaliste).